Running tasks on collections, automated or manual
A task on a collection changes the products in it when the task starts, and reverts every product it changed. The risk is overlap: a product in two targeted collections is in both sales, and the price changes can stack.
This applies to every collection you target. Shopify calls the ones that fill themselves by rules automated collections. You may also know them as smart collections or dynamic collections.
How do two sales end up on the same product?
Section titled “How do two sales end up on the same product?”A product is often in several collections at once: a category collection, a seasonal edit, a “new arrivals” list and an automated collection by vendor or type. If you schedule one task per collection, a product that belongs to two of them is in both tasks.
Here is an example. A coat priced $200 is in Winter coats and in Clearance.
| Step | Price of the coat |
|---|---|
| Before the sales | $200 |
| Task 1 starts on Winter coats (30% off) | $140 |
| Task 2 starts on Clearance (20% off), stacking on task 1 | $112 |
| Result | 44% off, not the 30% or 20% you planned |
The same happens with a collection and a tag, or a collection and a product type. A Flash Sale task and a Price Edit task on the same product can stack too.
What happens when one of the two tasks ends depends on its revert rule. See What happens when several tasks change the same product?
How do I avoid overlapping sales?
Section titled “How do I avoid overlapping sales?”Our advice: keep each product in one active task at a time.
- Check membership before you schedule. In Shopify admin, open a few products from each collection you plan to target. Each product page lists the collections it belongs to. If one product appears in two of your targets, the collections overlap.
- Use one task for a combined sale. If two collections should get the same discount, put both in one task instead of two. A product in both is then changed once.
- Tag the products you mean. For a sale whose products are spread across collections, add a tag such as
winter-saleto exactly the products you want, and target the tag (paid plans). A product carries the tag once, however many collections it is in. - Stagger tasks that must touch the same products. Let the first task end and revert before the next one starts. See Staggering tasks.
Do automated collections need extra care?
Section titled “Do automated collections need extra care?”Yes, when their conditions use price or compare-at price. A sale changes those values, so Shopify can move products into or out of the collection while the sale runs. Products that move out are still reverted. Do not count on products that move in during the sale being included in it.
A discount can move products into a collection such as Under $50. A task that starts on that collection after they have moved in picks them up, so they can then be in two sales. Our advice: check whether a sale price moves products into another collection you plan to target. Before targeting a price-based automated collection, test the task on a few specific products first and check the prices.
Collections built on tag, vendor or product type do not change when a price changes.
Should I edit a collection while a task targets it?
Section titled “Should I edit a collection while a task targets it?”Our advice: leave it as it is until the task has reverted. A product you remove is still reverted. Do not count on a product you add after the start being included in that sale. Adding a product to a collection that a second task targets can also create an overlap.
When you build a collection for a sale, add the products first. A product added to a collection takes time to settle, so a product added just before the task starts may not be picked up. Create or edit the collection, wait, then create the sale. Check that the products you expect are in the task.
Other ways to target products
Section titled “Other ways to target products”- Specific products. Select the products directly in the task. This works on every plan, including the Free plan, which covers 50 product variants in total across your active tasks.
- A tag. Targeting by tag needs a paid plan. In Shopify admin, select the products, use the bulk action to add a tag, then choose the tag under Target items.
- A manual collection. Targeting by collection needs a paid plan. Products join or leave it only when you change it.
If two sales have already stacked
Section titled “If two sales have already stacked”- Do not start new tasks on the same products.
- Note which products show the stacked price.
- Decide which sale should stay, then check the revert rule of the other one. With Price before this task (removes only this task), reverting it removes only that task. With Price before any task (removes all sales and price edits on the same products), the products go back to their price before both sales.
- Revert the other sale from the app dashboard. Reverting ends that sale on every product in it, not only the overlapping ones.
- Check the prices on a few products. If anything looks wrong, contact support@pricedip.app with the task names and the products affected.